Since the season 1958/1959 the Reynella Cricket Club’s premiership records are as follows:

1st XI Premierships (26)

14/15, 12/13, 08/09, 02/03, 01/02, 99/00, 98/99, 94/95, 86/87, 84/85, 79/80, 78/79, 77/78, 76/77, 75/76, 72/73, 71/72, 69/70, 68/69, 66/67, 65/66, 63/64, 62/63, 61/62, 60/61, 58/59

2nd XI Premierships (16)

16/17, 07/08, 01/02, 99/00, 98/99, 94/95, 91/92, 88/89, 85/86, 84/85, 83/84, 82/83, 73/74, 65/66, 64/65, 61/62

3rd XI Premierships (15)

14/15, 12/13, 09/10, 04/05, 02/03, 01/02, 00/01, 99/00, 98/99, 89/90, 88/89, 86/87, 85/86, 84/85, 72/73

4th XI Premierships (6)

11/12, 98/99, 95/96, 90/91, 88/89, 80/81

Women's Premierships (2)

18/19,19/20